Melinda Doolittle --
Blake Lewis -- Trite. Almost nothing. The song requires little singing talent, which is what he displayed, and his facial expressions were just piss-poor acting (kinda reminded me of how I sounded the first time I did Soft AC back when Soft AC was Soft AC). He may have blown it right here.
LaKisha JustWhatIsHerLastName?IHaveNoIdea.Oh,TheScreenSaysIt's"Jones" -- Hmmm...on one hand, that was really good. On the other, it was a little too CeCe Winans. And, on that famous third hand of mine, she made it obvious she couldn't reach Fantasia's level of performing that song. Hey, that's what the judges are saying, too.
Phil Stacey -- Hmmmm...Phil seems to be having some trouble with strategically making song choices. In other words, Phil can do this singing thing, but he keeps choosing songs he wants to do rather than songs that perfectly match him. This choice wasn't bad, but it wasn't an obviously perfect choice, either. Having said that, his performance wasn't bad.
Jordin Sparks -- Uh oh....risky song choice! Gotta make us cry to really pull it off! Ok....let's sit back and watch. Ooops...a slightly missed note. Okay...here we go...here we go....okay, I've gotten choked up...tears have come to my eyes...and...it's over. No flat-out crying. Oh, well. Still, I'll give her a 94/100! I thought Melinda would coast all the way...Melinda's definitely got serious competition.
____________________________________
Best: (tie) Melinda / Jordin
Worst: Blake
Should Go: Based on tonight, Blake
Will Go: I'm tempted to say it will definitely be one of the guys, but I'm thinking that LaKisha's song was too unfamiliar to most and not done well enough for those who would be familiar with it. Hmmm....I dunno!





